Two Towns, One Christmas
One of the most powerful symbols to this legacy can be found at the historic Penn Wells Hotel. There hangs a magnificent American flag, seven feet by eleven feet, crafted from more than 1,400 glass ornaments. Created by hotel employees in 1946, it honors returning World War II veterans and stands as a shining symbol of gratitude and resilience.
My own Christmas tree is filled with vintage and reproduction Shiny Brite ornaments, and I can say without hesitation that they now carry a far deeper meaning for me. Knowing their story has forever changed the way I see them.
Our Wellsboro adventure began the moment we arrived Friday evening. I was determined to see the gas lampposts glowing at night, and they more than lived up to my expectations. As we stepped out of the car, we heard music approaching, a parade! We arrived just in time to watch brightly lit floats, dancers, bands, and, of course, Mr. and Mrs. Claus pass by. Afterward, we enjoyed a lovely dinner at the Penn Wells Hotel, warming ourselves by the crackling lobby fire and admiring the majestic Christmas tree brushing the tall ceiling above.
Saturday was dedicated to exploring downtown, and the local businesses did not disappoint. While many were delightful, with their beautifully decorated windows, two stood out as true experiences.
The first was Dunham’s Department Store, a 112-year-old family-owned business and one of the last of its kind in the United States. With three floors and a wide array of merchandise, it brought back fond childhood holiday memories of stores like Montgomery Ward and G.C. Murphy. I left with shopping bags swinging at my sides.
Next, we visited Nessmuk’s Sporting Goods Store, which felt as much like a museum as a shop. Inside were displays devoted to hunting, fishing, camping, and trapping, along with canoes, vintage and modern firearms, and festively decorated taxidermy. Have you ever seen a turkey in a Santa hat? Well, I have along with a white-tailed buck pulling a sleigh, a beaver beneath a Christmas tree, and even a brown bear sporting a top hat. The sign out front proclaims it “The Coolest Store in Wellsboro,” followed by “says every man that walks in.” I believe they should add woman, because I enthusiastically agree.
Our final Wellsboro activity was a covered wagon ride through town. The beautifully decorated wagon was pulled by two Belgian horses, impeccably outfitted in black leather, silver-studded harnesses, and braided tails. It was picture-perfect. Our group was lively, and to the surprise of no one who knows me, I had the entire wagon singing “We Wish You a Merry Christmas” as we clip-clopped down the street.
It continued to snow all the way to Bethlehem, and when we awoke Sunday morning, nearly six inches blanketed the ground. Downtown Bethlehem had been transformed into a true winter wonderland. We wandered the snow-covered streets, visited local shops, and stopped at the historic Hotel Bethlehem.
One of the most meaningful highlights of our visit was Bitty & Beau’s Coffee. More than a coffee shop, it is a beacon of hope and inclusion for individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Founded by parents of two children with Down syndrome, Bitty and Beau, the shop now has 23 locations across the country. Their mission is simple and powerful: to provide meaningful employment and create genuine community connection. It was impossible to leave without feeling inspired.
Our final stop was the renowned Christkindlmarkt at SteelStacks, named one of the top holiday markets in the world. With artisan vendors, festive food, and numerous picture-worthy displays, it was easy to see why. We enjoyed lunch inside one of the cozy garden-dome igloos, a perfect ending to our Christmas tour.
As we turned the car toward home, we were tired, but in a wonderful way. We felt energized by the beauty, history, and kindness we encountered along the way. There is something deeply inspiring about stepping away, adventuring, and immersing oneself in the magic of the season, and something equally comforting about returning home with a heart full of memories. This journey reminded me that the true magic of Christmas isn’t just found in decorations or destinations, but in the stories, people, and moments that bring the season to life.
Rhonda S. Kelley, Executive Director
Juniata River Valley Chamber of Commerce